On Providence and the Continuity of Divine Causality
Quaeritur
Utrum providentia Dei sit continua causalitas, qua Deus non solum mundum ex nihilo creavit sed etiam ipsum in esse conservat et ad finem dirigit; et utrum haec causalitas non sit actio extrinseca vel occasionalis, sed praesentia interna, qua Deus per Verbum et Spiritum Sanctum causat esse, agere, et ordinari creaturas, ita ut simul conserventur contingentia, libertas, et bonum creationis.
Whether divine providence is a continuous causality by which God not only created the world from nothing but also preserves it in being and directs it to its end; and whether this causality is not an external or occasional action, but an inner presence, by which God through the Word and the Holy Spirit causes creatures to be, to act, and to be ordered, in such a way that contingency, freedom, and the goodness of creation are preserved.
Thesis
Locus classicus
Colossians 1:17
καὶ αὐτός ἐστιν πρὸ πάντων
καὶ τὰ πάντα ἐν αὐτῷ συνέστηκεν
He is before all things,
and in him all things hold together.
Acts 17:28
ἐν αὐτῷ γὰρ ζῶμεν καὶ κινούμεθα καὶ ἐσμέν
For in him we live and move and have our being.
These texts confess not a distant Creator but a present causality. The Logos is not merely the origin of the world but its abiding coherence. Providence is the ontological holding together of all that exists.
Explicatio
If creation is intelligible because it proceeds from the divine Word, then its intelligibility must endure only if that Word remains causally present. A creation that depended upon God only at its origin would not persist. It would lapse into nothingness the moment divine causality ceased. Providence therefore names not a secondary doctrine appended to creation but the inner truth of creation itself.
Creation is not a completed past event. It is an ongoing relation of dependence. To exist as a creature is to receive being continuously. The world does not possess existence as a stored property. It exists only as given, moment by moment, by divine causality.
This causality must be understood properly. Divine causation is not mechanical impulse, nor episodic intervention, nor competition with finite causes. God does not act alongside creatures as one cause among others. Rather, God causes creatures to be causes. Creaturely agency is real because it is grounded in divine causality, not despite it.
Here the traditional language of conservatio, concursus, and gubernatio names three aspects of a single act.
Conservatio names the preservation of being. Creatures continue to exist because God continuously wills and causes their existence.
Concursus names cooperation. God works in and through creaturely causes so that their actions are genuinely theirs, while still dependent upon divine causality.
Gubernatio names ordering. God directs all things toward their end without overriding the integrity of finite processes.
These are not successive acts. They are conceptual distinctions within one indivisible divine activity.
The Holy Spirit is the mode of this presence. The Spirit is not merely the giver of life in an initial sense but the living mediation of divine causality within the world. Through the Spirit, divine intention becomes the interior vitality of creation. The Spirit is the cause of continuity. He joins the Word’s creative causality to the temporal unfolding of creaturely existence.
This pneumatological mediation safeguards contingency and freedom. If divine causality were external, creaturely action would be either overridden or rendered illusory. If divine causality were absent, creaturely action would dissolve into randomness. The Spirit’s presence preserves the middle path. Creatures act freely because they are continuously enabled to act. Dependence upon God is not the negation of freedom but its condition.
Providence must therefore be distinguished from determinism. Determinism treats causality as compulsion. Divine causality is not compulsion but donation. God gives being and action without dictating the finite mode of their exercise. Because divine causality is deeper than finite causality, it does not displace it.
The problem of evil must be addressed within this framework. Providence encompasses all that exists insofar as it exists. Evil, however, is not a positive being but a privation. God causes the being of acts. He does not cause the defect within them. Finite freedom entails the possibility of failure. Providence does not eliminate this risk but orders it toward redemption. The cross stands as the decisive form of this ordering. What appears as negation becomes the place where divine faithfulness is most fully revealed.
Providence is therefore not an empirical hypothesis competing with natural explanation. It is a metaphysical confession concerning the ground of existence itself. Without providence, the world would not merely lack guidance. It would lack being.
Objectiones
Ob I. If divine causality is continuous and universal, then all events are determined by God and creaturely freedom is illusory.
Ob II. If God must continuously sustain creation, then creation is defective. A perfect creation would persist independently.
Ob III. If providence governs all things, then evil must be caused or willed by God.
Ob IV. The apparent randomness and suffering of the world contradict the claim that it is governed by providence.
Ob V. Modern relational and process theologies argue that divine causality must evolve with the world. Continuous causality appears static and incompatible with genuine novelty.
Responsiones
Ad I. Divine causality is not competitive with finite causality. It is constitutive. Freedom is preserved precisely because God causes the creature to act as a true cause.
Ad II. Dependence is not imperfection. Independence would negate creation itself. Continuous dependence is the form of creaturely existence.
Ad III. God causes being, not privation. Evil arises from finite freedom and limitation. Providence orders even failure toward redemption without authoring it.
Ad IV. Providence is discerned not in constant intervention but in intelligibility, persistence, and ordered meaning amid change.
Ad V. Divine causality is eternally active yet temporally manifest. God’s constancy grounds novelty rather than suppressing it.
Nota
Providence is best understood as creatio continua. The Word who speaks being into existence does not cease to speak. Every moment of being is the renewal of the creative fiat. This is not repetition in time but eternal presence.
The Spirit ensures that this causality is not mechanical necessity but personal faithfulness. Providence is promise enacted as ontology. The world endures not because it is self sufficient but because it is addressed continuously by God.
Thus the doctrine of providence secures three things simultaneously: the reality of divine sovereignty, the integrity of creaturely freedom, and the intelligibility of the world.
Determinatio
-
Providence is the continuous act of divine causality by which creation is preserved and ordered.
-
Divine causality is interior and constitutive, not external or competitive.
-
The Holy Spirit mediates this causality within creaturely action.
-
Creaturely freedom and contingency are grounded, not negated, by providence.
-
Evil is permitted within providence but not caused by God.
-
Providence completes the doctrine of creation as an ongoing relation of dependence.
Transitus ad Disputationem XIII
If divine causality is continuous, interior, and non competitive, then theology must ask how such causality can be spoken without distortion. Providence is not directly visible. It is confessed. It is named through finite language that must point beyond itself to an infinite act.
We therefore turn to the question of theological modeling and intensional meaning. How can language signify a causality that exceeds representation without collapsing into metaphor or mechanism? What is the relation between the conceptual content of theological terms and the reality they intend?
No comments:
Post a Comment